# Can a DC Insurer Refuse to Pay Because You Hired Your Own Contractor?

**Restoration Doctor of Washington DC** (VA Water Damage LLC dba Restoration Doctor)
Phone: (202) 922-1444 ((202) 922-1444) · office@restorationdoctors.com
Address: 4315 50th St NW Suite 100 #7112, Washington, DC 20016
Category: Insurance · Published: November 21, 2026 · Updated: November 21, 2026
Author: Steve Jafari, General Manager — https://restorationdoctordc.com/authors/steve-jafari

> TL;DR: We found no District statute and no condition in the standard homeowners form that makes using the insurer's contractor a condition of payment, and the District's insurance regulator says a homeowner can choose any contractor. That does not mean an insurer must pay whatever you are billed. Standard forms pay a reasonable, necessary cost for a covered loss, can hold back part of the payment until repairs are complete, and let the insurer elect in writing to make repairs itself. Some policies add managed-repair terms. The District's claims statute is enforced by the regulator, not through a private lawsuit.

![A single printed page on a dusty board floor beside a wall where broken plaster exposes the lath underneath.](https://restorationdoctordc.com/images/blog/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc-single-letter-on-floor-by-removed-baseboard-1600w.jpg)
*Illustrative only. A letter about payment is worth reading for the policy language it cites, or does not cite.*

## Can a DC insurer refuse to pay because you hired your own contractor?

Short answer first. We looked for a rule that lets an insurer refuse to pay a District homeowner because the homeowner hired a contractor of their own choosing, and we did not find one. The standard homeowners form does not list using the insurer's contractor among the things you must do after a loss. The District's insurance regulator, the Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking (DISB), tells homeowners in its consumer guide that "The homeowner can choose any contractor to make the repairs."

That is a narrower answer than "an insurer can never refuse." A policy pays what its terms promise, and several of those terms can reduce or reshape a payment whoever you hire. It is general information from a restoration contractor, not legal advice, and only your own policy governs your claim.

- No District statute we read ties payment to the insurer's contractor; we did not read the District's insurance regulations end to end
- Payment can still be limited to a reasonable cost, held back until repairs are complete, or replaced by the insurer's own repair where a policy allows it
- The District's claims statute is enforced by the regulator, against a pattern of conduct

## What does a standard homeowners policy make you do after a loss?

The policy quotations in this article come from the ISO HO 00 03 standard form (1991 edition), a homeowners form published by the Insurance Services Office. Later editions, and your own insurer's form, may word these clauses differently, so read them as an example of standard wording, not as your policy.

The form's conditions include a clause headed "Your Duties After Loss," which lists what you must see is done after a loss to covered property. Among the items: "Give prompt notice to us or our agent"; "Protect the property from further damage. If repairs to the property are required, you must: (1) Make reasonable and necessary repairs to protect the property; and (2) Keep an accurate record of repair expenses"; "As often as we reasonably require: (1) Show the damaged property; (2) Provide us with records and documents we request"; and "Send to us, within 60 days after our request, your signed, sworn proof of loss."

Read the whole list and one thing is absent: nothing in it says you must hire the insurer's contractor, or any contractor the insurer names. The list asks for notice, protection of the property, records, access to the damage and a sworn proof of loss. Those duties are real, and they apply whoever does the work. Hiring your own contractor is not on the list.

The same form's Loss Payment condition reads: "We will adjust all losses with you. We will pay you unless some other person is named in the policy or is legally entitled to receive payment." Payment in that clause runs to the policyholder. The clause does not mention the contractor.

## Is a smaller payment the same as a refusal?

No, and the difference matters. An insurer can pay less than a contractor's invoice without refusing anything, because standard wording caps the payment. Under the 1991 form's loss settlement terms for buildings, the insurer pays "not more than the least of" the policy limit, "The replacement cost of that part of the building damaged for like construction and use on the same premises," or "The necessary amount actually spent to repair or replace the damaged building."

Emergency work has its own measure. The form's Reasonable Repairs coverage says "we will pay the reasonable cost incurred by you for necessary measures taken solely to protect against further damage," and adds that it "Does not increase the limit of liability." The words reasonable and necessary do real work there. An insurer that considers a line unnecessary, or not reasonably priced, can pay less on that line. That is a dispute about amount, and it can arise whichever contractor you hire.

The form also holds money back until the work is done: "We will pay no more than the actual cash value of the damage until actual repair or replacement is complete." So a first payment smaller than the replacement estimate can follow from that clause alone, whoever you hired.

Where the amount is the disagreement, many policies include an appraisal clause. In the 1991 form it begins: "If you and we fail to agree on the amount of loss, either may demand an appraisal of the loss." How appraisal works on a District claim is covered in [the appraisal clause article](/blog/appraisal-clause-amount-dispute-dc), and comparing the two documents line by line is covered in [insurer estimate vs. contractor invoice](/blog/carrier-estimate-vs-contractor-invoice-dc).

![A single unmarked document lies alone on a plywood table in a gutted row-house room with exposed lath and brick behind it](https://restorationdoctordc.com/images/blog/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc-unmarked-estimate-plywood-table-1600w.jpg)
*Illustrative only. A reduced payment and a refusal can look alike on the page; the policy clause behind each is what differs.*

## When can the insurer take over the repair?

This is the clause that makes "you can always choose" too absolute. The 1991 form's "Our Option" condition says: "If we give you written notice within 30 days after we receive your signed, sworn proof of loss, we may repair or replace any part of the damaged property with like property." The ISO unit-owners form HO 00 06 (2000 edition) says the same in substance, with "material or property of like kind and quality."

In our reading, if an insurer gives that written notice for part of the damage, a homeowner who hires someone else for that same part may end up in a dispute about it. We do not know whether your policy has this clause or whether your insurer has used it. Check your policy, and take questions about it to your insurer, your agent, or a licensed public adjuster or attorney.

Some insurers go further with an endorsement, sometimes called option to repair or managed repair. A Florida insurer's published FAQ (Kin, updated July 28, 2026) says the company "may choose to invoke it after a covered loss," and that "Your role is rather small when the OTR is invoked." That is one Florida carrier, not a District rule. We did not find a managed-repair endorsement in use in the District, but we searched only the web, not insurers' form filings, so our search does not prove there is none. Check whether your policy lists one. Insurer programs are covered in more detail in [do you have to use your insurer's preferred contractor](/blog/insurer-preferred-contractor-choice-dc).

## What does District law do if an insurer refuses anyway?

Less than many homeowners assume, and it is better to know that now. The District's unfair claim settlement practices statute, [D.C. Code § 31-2231.17](https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/31-2231.17), lists conduct an insurer is not to engage in. The list includes: "Refuse to pay a claim for a reason that is arbitrary or capricious based on all available information"; "Refuse to pay claims without conducting a reasonable investigation"; and failing, "in the case of claims denials or offers of compromise settlement, to promptly provide a reasonable and accurate explanation of the basis for such action."

Two limits come with it. First, both of the statute's lists open with the same threshold: "No person shall commit or perform with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice any of the following." The statute reaches a pattern, not a single claim. Second, the chapter "shall be construed to permit an administrative remedy only, and nothing in this chapter shall be construed to create or imply a private cause of action for a violation of this chapter" ([§ 31-2231.02](https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/31-2231.02)). The Commissioner may impose "a penalty of up to $1,000 for each violation of subsection (a)." The Commissioner imposes it; the statute gives a homeowner no claim to collect it.

District common law does not fill the gap. In [Choharis v. State Farm, 961 A.2d 1080 (D.C. 2008)](https://dccourts.gov/sites/default/files/pdf-opinions/06-CV-234.PDF), the D.C. Court of Appeals declined to recognize a separate tort claim against an insurer for bad faith in handling its own policyholder's claim: "Although a common-law court, we are not persuaded that we should do so."

In our reading, that leaves a homeowner two real routes. The first is the policy itself, a contract between you and your insurer; a dispute over what it owes is a contract question for you and any attorney you hire. The second is a complaint to DISB, which tells residents: "If you believe you are being treated unfairly, contact DISB at (202) 727-8000 or online at disb.dc.gov." The 1991 form also has a "Suit Against Us" condition: "No action can be brought unless the policy provisions have been complied with and the action is started within one year after the date of loss." We did not research how District law treats that time limit; that is a question for an attorney.

![An open three-ring binder holding a ruled ledger page and loose sheets, on a metal folding chair in a narrow room.](https://restorationdoctordc.com/images/blog/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc-open-ring-binder-on-folding-chair-1600w.jpg)
*Illustrative only. The District's claims statute reaches patterns, and a pattern is visible only in kept records.*

## What does the complaint data show?

We could not find a District-specific count of complaints about insurers, let alone about contractor choice; we looked for DISB complaint statistics and did not locate them. The national figures are broader. ValuePenguin's analysis of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners' closed-complaint data for 2024 found that claim handling accounted for "65.2% of closed insurance complaints" across all lines. The same analysis lists "delays (22.2%)" and "unsatisfactory settlements or offers (12.2%)" among complaint reasons, and counts 15,161 homeowners insurance complaints, 18.0% of the total.

Those percentages cover every line of insurance and count complaints, not outcomes, and they say nothing about contractor choice. They do show that claim handling made up the majority of closed complaints in that data, which is a reason to keep the records described below from the first day.

## What records keep the question about the work, not the contractor?

In our view, most disputes that begin with who did the work turn on whether the work was needed and what it cost, and records answer those questions. DISB's guidance sets the order. "Before making any repairs, take photos of the damage," and "Save all related receipts, including those from temporary repairs." It adds that if you remove personal property from the home, "do not dispose of it until an adjuster from your insurance company has reviewed it for your claim."

- Photograph every affected room before anything is removed, and again as the work proceeds
- Keep every receipt, including those for emergency work and temporary repairs
- Keep removed belongings until the insurer's adjuster has reviewed them, as DISB advises
- Read your policy's duties after loss, any repair option and any endorsements, or ask your agent to walk you through them
- If a payment is reduced or refused, ask the insurer in writing for the policy language it relies on; DISB's guidance is to "ask the company for the specific language in the policy in question"
- If you believe you are being treated unfairly, contact DISB at (202) 727-8000

![A gray and blue air mover standing on a bare floor in front of a wall opening stripped back to studs and lath.](https://restorationdoctordc.com/images/blog/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc-stripped-closet-with-air-mover-1600w.jpg)
*Illustrative only. Photographs taken before and during the work show what was wet and why it came out.*

## What changes in a DC condo or co-op?

A unit owner's policy sits next to the association's master policy, and the two interact. The ISO unit-owners form HO 00 06 (2000 edition) sets apart, in its Other Insurance condition, a loss also covered by "insurance in the name of a corporation or association of property owners." In our reading, that usually leaves the master policy primary for building elements, and the association's insurer or board may control who repairs common or building elements. The same base form caps loss assessment coverage: "We will pay up to $1,000 for your share of loss assessment." That is a 2000 form, and current editions and endorsements vary.

So in a condo or co-op, the question of who may repair a pipe chase or a shared wall may be settled by the declaration, the bylaws and the master policy before your own policy is reached. Ask the association in writing who authorizes work on common elements. The sequence is covered in [water damage in a DC condo](/blog/condo-water-damage-claim-dc).

![A horizontal tide mark across plaster with the paint blistered and lifting along the line.](https://restorationdoctordc.com/images/blog/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc-tide-mark-blistered-plaster-1600w.jpg)
*Illustrative only. In a condo, whether a damaged wall is yours or the association's can decide who authorizes the repair.*

## Why do we think the choice should stay with you?

This section is Restoration Doctor's view, and we are a contractor with an interest in being hired, so weigh it with that in mind. We think the person who signs the work contract and owes the bill should choose who does the work, and DISB's guide describes the same structure: "The contractor always works for the homeowner." A contractor you hire directly answers to you, and its photographs, readings and invoice belong in your file.

There are limits on what we can do for you, and a statute sets them. In the District, a public insurance adjuster includes anyone who, "for compensation or any other thing of value," acts or aids "on behalf of an insured individual in negotiating for, or effecting the settlement of, a claim for loss or damage covered by an insurance contract" ([§ 31-1631.02(5)(A)](https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/31-1631.02)). And "No person shall, directly or indirectly, act as a public insurance adjuster without first procuring a license" ([§ 31-1631.03](https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/31-1631.03)).

We are a restoration contractor, not a public adjuster. We invoice the property owner and give the owner a complete file of our work. We do not interpret your policy, negotiate with your insurer or represent you in a claim; those roles belong to you, a licensed public adjuster or an attorney. The line is set out in [what a DC restoration contractor cannot do](/blog/what-a-restoration-contractor-cannot-do-dc).

## Where can a District owner read these rules firsthand?

Every quotation above comes from a document anyone can open. The ISO form text is a 1991 edition used as an example; your policy may use a later edition or your insurer's own wording. Questions about coverage belong with your insurer, your agent, or a licensed public adjuster or attorney.

Sources referenced in this article:

- District of Columbia Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking, [Things You Should Know When Selecting a Contractor](https://disb.dc.gov/page/things-you-should-know-when-selecting-contractor), consumer guide, accessed November 21, 2026
- District of Columbia Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking, [Five Reminders About Your Insurance Coverage](https://disb.dc.gov/page/five-reminders-about-your-insurance-coverage), revised February 2023, accessed November 21, 2026
- District of Columbia Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking, [filing property insurance claims after storm damage](https://disb.dc.gov/node/563242), accessed November 21, 2026
- Code of the District of Columbia, [§ 31-2231.17, unfair claim settlement practices](https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/31-2231.17), accessed November 21, 2026
- Code of the District of Columbia, [§ 31-2231.02, general prohibition and administrative remedy](https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/31-2231.02), accessed November 21, 2026
- Code of the District of Columbia, [Chapter 22A full text, unfair insurance trade practices](https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/titles/31/chapters/22A/index.full.html), searched for the words repair and contractor with no result, accessed November 21, 2026
- Code of the District of Columbia, [§ 31-1631.02](https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/31-1631.02) and [§ 31-1631.03](https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/31-1631.03), public insurance adjusters, accessed November 21, 2026
- District of Columbia Court of Appeals, [Choharis v. State Farm, 961 A.2d 1080 (D.C. 2008)](https://dccourts.gov/sites/default/files/pdf-opinions/06-CV-234.PDF), accessed November 21, 2026
- Insurance Services Office, [HO 00 03 homeowners special form, 1991 edition, specimen posted by the Nevada Division of Insurance](https://doi.nv.gov/uploadedfiles/doinvgov/_public-documents/Consumers/Home/American_Family/Homesite_HO_00_03_04_91.pdf), accessed November 21, 2026
- Insurance Services Office, [HO 00 06 unit-owners form, 2000 edition, specimen copy](https://www.independentagent.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/HO00061000.pdf), accessed November 21, 2026
- Kin Insurance, [option to repair FAQ](https://kin.com/faq/option-to-repair), updated July 28, 2026, a Florida carrier, accessed November 21, 2026
- ValuePenguin, [most common insurance complaints, an analysis of NAIC closed-complaint data](https://www.valuepenguin.com/most-common-insurance-complaints), 2024 data, accessed November 21, 2026


## Frequently asked questions

### Can my insurance company deny my claim because I didn't use its contractor?

We found no District statute and no condition in the standard homeowners form that makes the insurer's contractor a condition of payment, and the District's insurance regulator says a homeowner can choose any contractor. Payment still depends on your policy's terms. In the standard form those include a reasonable cost, your duties after a loss and an option for the insurer to make repairs itself. Questions about a specific denial belong with your insurer, your agent, or a licensed public adjuster or attorney.

### Why did my insurer pay less than my contractor's invoice?

The standard homeowners form pays the least of the policy limit, the replacement cost for like construction, or the necessary amount actually spent, and it can hold back part of the payment until repairs are complete. A smaller payment can be a dispute about amount rather than a refusal. You can ask your insurer in writing for the specific policy language behind each reduction.

### Is there a DC law that stops insurers from steering me to their contractor?

We did not find one. A full-text search of the District's unfair insurance trade practices chapter found no provision on repairs or contractors. What the District has is regulator guidance saying a homeowner may select a contractor the insurer suggests but is not required to do so.

### Can I sue my insurer for bad faith in DC?

In Choharis v. State Farm (2008), the D.C. Court of Appeals declined to recognize a separate tort for an insurer's bad faith in handling its own policyholder's claim, and the District's claims-practices chapter allows an administrative remedy only. A dispute over what your policy owes is a contract question for an attorney, and complaints about claim handling go to DISB.

### What should I keep if I hire my own contractor?

DISB advises photographing the damage before making any repairs, saving all related receipts including those from temporary repairs, and not disposing of removed personal property until your insurer's adjuster has reviewed it. Keep your contractor's photographs, moisture readings and invoice in the same file.

## Related reading

- Do You Have to Use Your Insurer's Preferred Contractor in DC? — https://restorationdoctordc.com/blog/insurer-preferred-contractor-choice-dc
- Who Pays the Restoration Company in DC — https://restorationdoctordc.com/blog/who-pays-restoration-company-dc
- Insurer Estimate vs. Contractor Invoice in DC — https://restorationdoctordc.com/blog/carrier-estimate-vs-contractor-invoice-dc
- What a DC Restoration Contractor Cannot Do — https://restorationdoctordc.com/blog/what-a-restoration-contractor-cannot-do-dc
- Water Damage Restoration in Washington, DC — https://restorationdoctordc.com/services/water-damage-restoration

---
Source page: https://restorationdoctordc.com/blog/insurer-refuse-pay-own-contractor-dc
Blog index: https://restorationdoctordc.com/blog
Reviews: https://restorationdoctorsreviews.com
Phone: (202) 922-1444 ((202) 922-1444)
Last updated: October 2026
